Guest Articles

“Social Anger and Apathy in Pakistan” by AKHTER ALI SYED

A Psychopathological Perspective in Neo-Colonial Era. The thesis shall be published in 7 episodes. A detail of the references shall be given in the last episode.

The attacks on twin towers in September 2001 changed the world. If it is true, it is yet to be determined whether the “attacks” changed the world or the way they were responded to. A lot has been said, written and done about it but as suggested, the world is, being perceived as more unsafe than before 9/11. Beside the feelings of horror, uncertainty and dismay, which went high among the masses, the biggest psychological damage caused by 9/11 and its aftermath, was the negative perception people of different regions, religions and cultures have developed about each other. Thesis of the “Clash of Civilization” became a hot topic a decade after of its writing. The task of analyzing the situation was given to the misinformation experts (Ali et al 2011) and their analysis of incidents on 9/11 was aired by the corporate media. Pakistan received its share of blame in the analysis as it had previously launched a unique war against the communist Soviet Union. As it has been suggested Pakistan has designed, preached and exported the legacy of extremism to the Muslim world to get as many recruits as possible. The extremists in Pakistan, as it was analyzed, are strong, powerful and big in numbers so that no Government in Islamabad can control them. In addition, the nuclear assets could go into extremist’s hands at any time. The perception of “extremist Pakistan” resonated so strong in the West that as soon as one may view a book with a title of bearded and turbaned youth shouting, one would relate it to Pakistan.

The West prefers to view Pakistan through a single optic. European and North American papers give the impression that the main, if not the only, problem confronting Pakistan is the powers of the bearded fanatics skulking in Hindu Kush, who, as the papers see it, are on the verge of taking over the country (Ali 2008, p.4).

Some Western analysts believe that these “bearded fanatics” have the benefit of the mass support in Pakistan.

When terrorist groups attack India, or Western forces in Afghanistan, their actions enjoy a degree of instinctive, gut sympathy from a majority of Pakistanis – not because of Islamist extremism, but because of Muslim nationalism and bitter hostility to the US role in the Muslim world in general and Pakistan’s region in particular (Lieven 2011, p.5)

The message Western analysts try to communicate is, that although a majority is not involved in carrying out terrorist attacks, it shares the ideology and morally espouse the activities of terrorists.

Radicalization of Pakistani society is a notion which has been used very loosely and often superficially. The three definitions of the phenomenon of “radicalization” quoted before the participants of a debate organized by Pak Institute for Peace were a reflection of a particular political and oriental context (PIPS 2009). However, the terrorist attacks, bomb blasts, attacks on military instillations still needed to be comprehended and explained. Pakistan lost 36,000 innocent men and $70 billion in fighting against the terrorism. (Al Arabiya News 2012). Some other sources show some different figures.

 Table: 1. Annual Fatalities in Terrorist Violence in Pakistan, 2003- Feb. 2012

Year Civilians Security Force Personnel Terrorists/Insurgents Total
2003 140 24 25 189
2004 435 184 244 863
2005 430 81 137 648
2006 608 325 538 1471
2007 1522 597 1479 3598
2008 2155 654 3906 6715
2009 2324 991 8389 11704
2010 1796 469 5170 7435
2011 2580 765 2797 6142
Feb. 2012 325 176 427 988
Total 12315 4266 23112 39693

(Source: http://www.satp.org/satporgtp/countries/pakistan/database/casualties.htm)

No social institution, religious group or a political party (except few religious ones) could escape being the target of terrorists. Mosques, Imambargah, shrines of Saints, Markets, schools, political and religious gatherings and even funeral processions have been targeted by terrorists. Syed (2011) suggested that Pakistan is setting new trends for suicide attacks. There are a number of reasons; he refers to, which make Pakistan an exclusive case to study.

The regions known to have frequent suicide attacks have two main motivations, foreign occupation (like in Iraq and Afghanistan) and a liberation movement (similar to the Palestine and Sri Lanka). Pakistan is the only country enduring frequent suicide attack without having any of the above mentioned reasons. Syed (2011) made an important finding about the pattern of suicide attacks in Pakistan. “Like Iraq, suicide attackers in Pakistan have no single agenda to run or a specific group to target. From masses to mosques, from security forces to clerics of other sects, from children to religious processions a wide range of people have remained the targets. Other regions, like Israel and Sri Lanka, targets of suicide attacks were known, predictable and were relevant in the political crisis of the particular region.” (Syed 2011.  p. 85).

These violent trends are considered a portrayal of social anger in Pakistani society. In August 2010, Sialkot, a notable industrial city of Pakistan witnessed a lynch mob killing of two brothers in the presence of Police officers and hundreds of bystanders. In August 2009, four women, a man and a child all belonging to the Christian community were murdered by a mob in Gojra. In January 2011, the Governor of Punjab was killed by his own security guard as his comments on one law annoyed the murderer. Religious leaders refused to perform his funeral service. Rather, his murderer was showered with petals on his arrival to the court. Many lawyers proudly advocated the murderer’s case as they were all annoyed with the slain Governor. In the case of petty crimes, if a mob apprehends, the perpetrators are generally beaten to death or burnt alive.  This level and nature of violence is a hot topic for journalists, political analysts, politicians and for academic circles. Several experts have attempted to investigate these trends from their respective perspectives.

A number of approaches are employed to interpret the situation in Pakistan. The majority of analysts have attempted to view the current troubled situation from the perspective of the situation emerged after the Russian invasion in Afghanistan and its after-effects on the region in general and Pakistan in particular  (Akbar, 2011; Ali 2008; Leiven, 2011). Some have used the current scene of International politics and country’s internal structures to explain the current state (Jones 2002). Some analysts employed the religious history of the subcontinent as a factor in explaining the current trends of violence in the region (Jalal 2008). While some have tried to investigate into the events leading to 9/11 and its aftermath (Rashid 2008). Ahmed (2011), looked into these violent trends from the confines of sectarian schism in Pakistan.

It may be argued that what is the source of this anger which has encouraged such violent acts of terrorism? In the last decade a number of hypotheses have been proposed. Esposito and Mogahed (2007) analyzed the hypotheses suggested about the sources of anger, radicalization and terrorism among the Muslim community. As it is suggested that these violent trends are the outcome of an abnormal, deranged and irrational mindset (psychological hypothesis), the terrorists are socially misfit, alienated and lacking education (sociological hypothesis), they belong to poor and lower economic groups of society (economic hypothesis), they abhor democracy and averse human rights and modern concepts of freedom (political hypothesis), they are radicals, fanatics, believe in violence (religious hypothesis).

Robert Pape (2005), in his study did not find any psychological disorder in the perpetrators of suicide attacks, the most lethal form of terrorism and violence. The attackers involved in 9/11 were well educated and most of them belonged to wealthy families. The attackers involved in the London bombing were well educated, belonged to middle class families and some of them were born in the UK. For instance, the British born, Omer Sheikh who was convicted for the Wall Street Journal’s Daniel Pearl’s murder was educated at the London School of Economics.  Pape (2005), Esposito & Mogahed (2007) rejected the religious hypothesis for several reasons. One, terrorism is not exclusively a Muslim phenomenon, two, many terrorists were not practicing Muslims and three, in many instances they knew very little about religion.

What are the psycho-social factors involved in terrorism in different regions of the world? Is there any relationship between International terrorism and the situation in Pakistan? Do the above mentioned hypotheses provide any help to understand and explain the situation in Pakistan? Syed (2011), made a forceful assertion on the exceptionality and matchlessness of the situation in Pakistan in terms of violence and suicide terrorism. He concluded that it is very difficult, if not impossible to find one reason for the phenomenon of violence in Pakistan. Should we look for some other viable hypothesis or paradigm to explain the badly troubled psycho-social conditions in Pakistan?

Anger: A Multilayered Phenomenon?

From Ancient Philosophers to Medieval Thinkers and up to modern times theories of anger keep evolving. The significant difference, in recent thinkers theories is an attempt to understand it instead of simply condemning it. This may be the main reason why social thinkers (mainly Psychologists) are more focused on its causes. Izard (1991), identified five major causes of anger; 1) restraint, 2) blocking or interrupting of goal directed activity 3) aversive stimulation, 4) being misled or unjustly hurt, 5) moral indignation. In his views, it is a complex emotion and a combination of disgust, contempt and of adaptation. Izrad made some interesting observations. He suggested that leaving anger unexpressed could cause serious health issues. In his views, anger is not the only cause of aggression rather “appropriate expression of justified anger may even strengthen the relationship between the angry person and the person who is the target of anger”. (p. 209)

Lazarus (1991) views anger as an outcome of harm, loss or threat, which needs someone to blame (for inflicting harm, loss or threat). He argued how people struggle for the preservation of their ego identity and any assault to that causes anger. This type and severity of this anger depends on two factors, 1) personality and 2) recent patterns of individual’s being demeaned. In his words, anger in adults is incited by “a demeaning offence against me and mine” (p. 221), and even a minor obstruction could be considered as demeaning.

Averill (1982) defined this conflicting emotion at three different levels of human existence. From the biological perspective anger is “related to aggressive systems and, even more important, to the capacities for co-operative social living, symbolization and reflective self-awareness”. From the psychological viewpoint anger “aimed at correction of some appraised wrong”. Finally, at the sociocultural outlook anger “functions to uphold accepted standards of conduct” (p. 317).

Lazarus (1991) emphasized “appraisal” and its role on anger’s expression and connection with violence. If the result of angry individual’s appraisal suggests that the expression of anger might have to encounter with strong reaction, expression is generally curtailed. However, it can cause an attack if it is considered as the best way to cope with an offence.

Theorists and researchers focused on collective and social anger and tried identifying its different shapes. Anderson & Bushman (2002), after reviewing the literature concluded that anger is the driving force behind hostile aggression and violence which is considered as thoughtless and impulsive but with the primary objectives of harming the target. According to Berkowitz and Geen, (Anderson & Bushman, p. 37), there are five reasons for anger being responsible for aggression which targets and harms others. Firstly, anger minimizes inhibition and provides justifications for hostile aggression. Secondly, anger helps in keeping the aggressive intentions and in designing the aggressive plans. Thirdly, cognitively, anger works as a resource for information, causes, culpability and the possible ways of responding. Fourthly, “anger primes aggressive thoughts, scripts and associated expressive-motor behaviors” (p. 37). Fifthly, anger enhances and energizes the arousal system to cause a behavioral response, i.e., aggression and hostility.

The difficult and lethal aspect of anger is when it takes a collective (or social) shape and when a group of people start sharing the same nature, reason and level of anguish and tend to act collectively. When anger turns into aggression and further changes into collective violence, it not only an expressive phenomenon but becomes a tool for social control (Roche, 1996). Roche is of the opinion that the nature and direction of human behavior is determined by the location of its social setting. The theme around which in Roche’s view, collective violence revolves is “social control” as a strategy of “self help”. Self help is not necessarily a violent strategy but may include lower levels of aggression, “manners of insults, taunts, criticisms, and protests, as well as vandalism, arson” (p.101).  He focused on four forms of unilateral collective violence, lynching, rioting, vigilantism, and terrorism. He differentiated them on two grounds, liability and degree of organization involved. Lynching and rioting would require a relatively lower level of organization but for vigilantism and terrorism a higher level of collective action would be involved. Lynching and rioting are temporary but vigilantism and terrorism are not. Roche (1996) drew ten inferences about collective violence.

1) The severity of collective violence will be high if the people in conflict participate more in one another’s lives. 2) Cultural distance increases the probability and severity of all four forms of collective violence. 3) The groups which cooperate with one another, economically, politically or socially are comparatively unlikely to attack each other. 4) Inequality in terms of wealth and other variables increases the likelihood of collective violence of all four forms as it provides social control. 5) In case of social polarization the collective liability of collective violence is less. 6) Individuals and their behaviors are more liable for collective violence in less polarized society. 7) Vigilantism is high in case of repeated deviant behaviors like, thefts, robberies and violations of moral standards. 8) Rioting is more related to the polarization of society than the deviant behavior. 9) The organization requires for collective violence is directly linked with the continuation of deviant behavior and similarly 10) terrorism will also be related with the continuation of deviant behavior but with the polarization of society as well.

Note: The Article has been published before and has not been updated.

Dr. Akhter Ali Syed is a famous Psychologist and writer. He is currently working in Ireland as Principal Psychologist. He also has a keen interest in Philosophy, religions, History and Humanity.

 

 

 

Facebook Comments
28 Comments

28 Comments

  1. เพิ่มยอดไลค์

    September 4, 2018 at 3:56 pm

    Likely I am likely to save your blog post. 🙂

  2. Like

    September 3, 2018 at 3:56 pm

    Like!! I blog quite often and I genuinely thank you for your information. The article has truly peaked my interest.

  3. eebest8 fiverr

    June 23, 2018 at 12:18 pm

    “Thanks a lot for the article post. Much obliged.”

  4. Predrag Timotic

    May 23, 2018 at 10:23 am

    743093 179818Can you give me some suggestions for piece of software writing? 612812

  5. hoverboard

    May 22, 2018 at 11:31 pm

    662778 868080I truly got into this article. I discovered it to be fascinating and loaded with special points of interest. I like to read material that makes me feel. Thank you for writing this excellent content. 684953

  6. forex signals

    May 20, 2018 at 6:15 am

    825596 505291Hello there, just became alert to your weblog by way of Google, and discovered that it is genuinely informative. Im gonna watch out for brussels. Ill be grateful if you continue this in future. Several men and women will probably be benefited from your writing. Cheers! 169603

  7. DMPK studies team

    May 15, 2018 at 8:24 am

    214289 771499How much of an exciting piece of writing, continue creating companion 342003

  8. scribd vs amazon unlimited

    May 13, 2018 at 1:02 am

    652710 603982Any way Im going to be subscribing for a feed and I hope you write-up once more soon 329222

  9. C++ Tutorial

    April 30, 2018 at 4:17 pm

    818368 646658Sorry for the huge review, but Im truly loving the new Zune, and hope this, as well as the excellent reviews some other men and women have written, will aid you decide if it is the proper choice for you. 914813

  10. diyala coee

    April 26, 2018 at 12:41 am

    367934 244267I like this post, enjoyed this one appreciate it for putting up. 581513

  11. ar iq

    April 19, 2018 at 6:03 pm

    282009 976172Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers? Im kinda paranoid about losing everything Ive worked hard on. Any suggestions? 670011

  12. board game news

    April 13, 2018 at 6:10 pm

    Very interesting details you have observed, thank you for posting.

  13. 246139 530583Properly written articles like yours renews my faith in todays writers. Youve written information I can finally agree on and use. Thank you for sharing. 74391

  14. organic traffic from SEO

    March 30, 2018 at 6:09 pm

    504448 539576Dead composed topic matter, thanks for info . 712275

  15. CPNS 2018 Kota Parepare

    February 27, 2018 at 7:05 am

    692392 602747This kind of lovely weblog youve, glad I found it!?? 924182

  16. page

    February 27, 2018 at 6:06 am

    35806 806297I surely did not understand that. Learnt 1 thing new today! Thanks for that. 724519

  17. warehouse for rent

    February 5, 2018 at 10:12 am

    808699 421712An fascinating discussion is worth comment. I think that you should write much more on this subject, it might not be a taboo topic but usually men and women are not enough to speak on such topics. Towards the next. Cheers 645004

  18. http://www.guaranteedppc.com

    February 3, 2018 at 2:42 pm

    577805 535217There is noticeably a bundle comprehend this. I suppose you created specific nice points in functions also. 275008

  19. Pharmacokinetic studies

    January 23, 2018 at 3:17 am

    575526 301933But a smiling visitant here to share the adore (:, btw excellent style and design . 663501

  20. GVK Biosciences

    January 19, 2018 at 9:30 am

    590524 470522As I web site owner I conceive the content material material here is rattling excellent , thanks for your efforts. 232365

  21. info lowongan kerja cpns 2019

    January 9, 2018 at 10:42 am

    527612 208064Should you are interested in envision a alter in distinct llife, starting up usually the Los angeles Surgical procedures fat reduction method is a large movement as a way to accomplishing which usually thought. shed belly fat 806442

  22. syarat daftar cpns 2018

    January 9, 2018 at 10:32 am

    200490 856103Overall, politicians are split on the issue of whether Twitter is much more for business or private use. The first thing could be the fact that you can build up quite a large following of folks. 331778

  23. GVK BIO pvt ltd

    December 30, 2017 at 1:32 pm

    897390 430215I enjoy the useful info you give inside your articles. 426516

  24. cpns guru jalur umum 2018

    December 25, 2017 at 8:18 pm

    701650 464529I adore gathering helpful information, this post has got me even a lot more information! . 71544

  25. geo

    December 25, 2017 at 3:54 pm

    729317 435278Most reliable human being messages, nicely toasts. are already provided gradually during the entire wedding celebration and therefore are anticipated to be extremely laid back, humorous and as properly as new all at once. greatest man speech 486969

  26. manutenção informática

    December 22, 2017 at 11:19 pm

    35728 858769Fascinating website, i read it but i nonetheless have a couple of questions. shoot me an email and we will talk a lot more becasue i could have an interesting idea for you. 651869

  27. informatica empresa

    December 15, 2017 at 11:19 pm

    110763 741294Hello there! Nice post! Please inform us when all could see a follow up! 916451

  28. Aws is the best engineer in diyala

    November 4, 2017 at 4:07 pm

    531190 65970Definitely,Chilly location! We stumbled on the cover and Im your personal representative. limewire limewire 595680

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top
Shares